Fuelman vs. Voyager: Fleet Fuel Card Comparison Guide [2025]

Managing fuel costs is one of the biggest challenges for any business fleet. Choosing the right fuel card can make all the difference, helping you control expenses and simplify reporting. Two of the most popular options for businesses, Fuelman and Voyager, both offer nationwide acceptance, detailed reporting tools, and strong security features, but they differ in key areas like fees, coverage, and customer experience.

In this comparison, we’ll break down the major differences between Fuelman and Voyager, including accepting locations, discounts, fees, reviews, fraud protection, and controls. By the end, you’ll know which card best fits your fleet.

Table of Contents

• Fuelman vs. Voyager: overview
• Accepting locations
• Discounts
• Fees
• Reviews
• Fraud protection
• Controls and reporting
• Which fuel card is best for your business?
  
  

Fuelman vs. Voyager: Overview

Use this chart to quickly compare both fuel card companies. The data comes from their official websites and trusted third party reviews to show the key differences.

Fuelman vs. Voyager: Accepting Locations 

Fuelman and Voyager are both universal fuel cards, accepted at gas stations and truck stops nationwide. However, Voyager offers broader coverage, with acceptance at over 320,000 fuel and maintenance locations compared to Fuelman’s 60,000 participating fuel sites making Voyager the clear winner when it comes to network size.

See accepting locations for each fuel card:

• Find Fuelman locations
• Find Voyager locations 

✅Pro tip: Start by checking which fuel cards are accepted at the stations your business already uses. Then, compare the discounts each card offers at those locations to see which provides the best value.

Fuelman vs. Voyager: Discounts 

Fuelman offers an 8¢ per gallon rebate at 40,000 locations with its Mixed Fleet Card and a 12¢ per gallon rebate on diesel with the Diesel Fleet Card. Voyager also provides rebates at select locations, which vary by brand and typically range from 3–8¢ per gallon. Overall, Fuelman leads in the discount category with more participating stations, but it’s worth comparing fuel card discounts at the stations your fleet uses to see which card offers the best savings.

Fuelman vs. Voyager: Fuel Card Fees 

Fuelman offers three subscription plans; Basic ($39/month), Pro ($59/month), and Enterprise ($99/month). Each plan covers all cards on the account rather than charging per card. There’s also a $3 fee per transaction when fueling at extended network locations. Voyager includes all features, support, and fraud coverage for free.

Voyager is the winner in the fuel card fees category as it's one of the lowest cost fuel cards on the market.

✅Pro tip: See if Fuelman's discounts cover the monthly subscription fee for the plan you want. If not, you may want to consider the Voyager card.

Fuelman vs. Voyager: Reviews

Voyager holds a higher Trustpilot rating at 4.8 out of 5 stars, compared to Fuelman’s 2.4 stars. Take time to read customer reviews for each company to see what users appreciate and what common issues they mention. You can also see how Voyager and Fuelman match up to other fuel cards in this fleet fuel card review comparison guide.

✅Pro tip: Call each fuel card provider’s support line to gauge their customer service and see how quickly they can resolve issues.

Fuelman vs. Voyager: Fraud Protection

Both Fuelman and Voyager have systems in place to monitor and flag suspicious transactions. Fuelman offers fraud loss coverage of $10K per card, or up to $25k per account, per year with Pro and Enterprise plans. Fuelman’s Basic plan does not offer fraud loss coverage. Voyager offers free fraud coverage if card skimming occurs. 

Fuelman vs. Voyager: Fuel Card Controls and Reporting 

Fuelman and Voyager are both closed-loop fuel cards, offering stronger security than open-loop fuel cards that operate on credit card networks. Each provides customizable controls, driver profiles, and real time alerts, along with detailed fuel reports to track purchases, manage expenses, and simplify IFTA reporting. Both are strong options, delivering advanced fleet management tools that are easy to access through their online portals.

✅Pro tip: Make a list of the specific goals your business wants to achieve, and ask each sales team how their fuel card can help you reach them. This helps ensure you choose a card with the right features for your needs.

Fuelman vs. Voyager: Which Card is Best for Your Business?

Choosing between Fuelman and Voyager ultimately depends on your fleet’s priorities. If your business values wider acceptance, no monthly fees, and strong customer satisfaction, Voyager is the better fit. It’s accepted at nearly every fuel station in the U.S., offers free fraud protection, and has one of the highest Trustpilot ratings among fuel cards.

Fuelman, on the other hand, may be a better option if your fleet can take advantage of its higher per gallon rebates and doesn’t mind paying a monthly subscription. With up to 12¢ off per gallon on diesel and access to detailed controls and reporting, Fuelman can still deliver strong savings, especially for fleets that primarily use its discount network.

If you’re interested in exploring more fuel card options, take a look at the 10 Best Fleet Fuel Cards for Business [2025]. This guide compares leading universal, cardlock, and over-the-road (OTR) fuel cards on the market. You can also learn more about the P-Fleet Voyager Fuel Card or apply online to get started.