<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=114819295626675&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
APPLY NOW
CONTACT US

Understanding the Best Fuel Card Programs

The right fuel card helps your business track spending, access discounts and save money overall. P-Fleet fuel cards allow you to customize spending limits and easily track purchases with zero transaction, late payment or setup fees.

Fuel card comparison

Cards for fleet fueling are sometimes referred to as fuel credit cards, gas cards, fuel cards or fleet cards. Although descriptions vary, the purpose is the same  help businesses manage diesel and gas purchases. 

By providing access to convenient locations, reducing unauthorized spending and enabling expenses to be tracked more easily, fleet management fuel cards are an essential tool for owner-operators, businesses and trucking companies. Belowwe summarize a few of the best fuel cards and the pros and cons of different card types.

Universal fuel cards

Universal cards, such as Voyager or WEX, are some of the best fuel cards for companies that value convenience. With access to over 90% of all fuel locations in the U.S., drivers can easily find gas or diesel when they need to fill up.

These cards provide purchase controls to limit fueling by the time of day, day of the week, number of transactions and spend per day, week or month. Level III data is captured at 99.5% of sitesso you know the card number, dollar amount, gallons, fuel type, date, time and location for each purchase. Discounts are often limited to the largest fleets and may include fees, so check your customer terms and conditions carefully.

 

Pros
  • Universal acceptance
  • Optional maintenance
  • Purchase controls
  • Level III data
Cons
  • Limited discounts

Fuel credit cards

Business fuel credit cards are affiliated with vendors like Visa or MasterCard and are often issued by companies like Comdata, Fleetcor or US Bank. Unlike traditional credit cards, purchases can be restricted to gas stations and other merchant codes. While purchase controls are present, they normally can't be adjusted with the same specificity as the controls on universal or cardlock cards. In addition, 5%-10% of fuel sites lack the technology to capture Level III data and provide consistent purchase controls that are often essential for effective fleet management.

 

Pros
  • Universal acceptance
  • Optional maintenance
  • Level III data at most sites
Cons
  • Limited discounts
  • Gaps in controls
  • Gaps in data capture

Major oil and fuel cards

Many major oil companies offer co-branded cards with a rebate or discount at their own gas stations. However, because these cards are intended to drive traffic to their own brands, the number of sites available to customers can be less than other options. 

These discounts or rebates are often capped at a certain dollar amount, limited to a set number of gallons or only available during the first few months once a customer signs up. Carefully review the fine print on rebates and discounts before applying. Purchase controls should be similar to universal cards but can vary significantly among card providers.

 

Pros
  • Rebates or discounts (on qualifying purchases)
  • Purchase controls
Cons
  • Limited to a specific brand
  • Rebate amounts capped
  • Extra fees can offset savings

Cardlock network cards

The Commercial Fueling Network (CFN) and Pacific Pride are the two largest cardlock networks in the U.S. with sites designed to accommodate commercial vehicles. 

Often, sites are conveniently located near major freeways and within metro areas. They usually include features like high-speed fueling and satellite pumps so that drivers can refuel quickly. Many fleet managers prefer these card options because of the potential discounts as well as the industry-leading controls.

Using cardlock network cards is advantageous for controlling what your drivers can purchase once they reach a fuel site. Whether you want to set restrictions on how much can be purchased to match tank capacity, the type of fuel your drivers can purchase or the hours of the day drivers are allowed to make a purchase, you gain significant control and oversight of your operations with a cardlock network card.

CFN cards offer access to over 3,000 discount fuel sites nationwide, with many locations in the West. Trucking and business fleets can expand coverage by adding access to 57,000 retail stations and truck stops. However, while these extra retail locations offer greater convenience, they normally don't facilitate discounted prices.

 

Pros
  • Discount pricing
  • Industry-best controls
  • Sites for larger vehicles
  • Level III data
Cons
  • Select retail acceptance
  • No discounts at retail sites
  • No maintenance

Over the road fuel cards (OTR cards)

OTR cards are accepted at various truck stop brands across the U.S. These cards are ideal for long-haul trucking operations. The larger tank capacity of trucks means drivers can go farther before stopping to refuel. They don't need access to as many fueling locations as other drivers of vehicles with smaller tanks.

Although they can get by with fewer locations, long-haul truckers often need access to truck stops with various driver services and amenities like restaurants, showers and overnight parking. Some OTR cards enable drivers to pay for these services.

While OTR cards might offer discounts on fuel, some cards charge transaction fees and other account fees. Another potential issue is that OTR cards are well-known for having lower credit limits and shorter billing terms than other payment options, so carefully review the fine print before signing up.

 

Pros
  • Truck stop discounts
  • Driver services
Cons
  • Limited number of sites
  • Transaction fees
  • Shorter credit terms

Not sure which fleet credit card is right for you?

Our team can help you determine which card is the right fit for your needs.

 

SPEAK TO A SPECIALIST

Benefits of using a fuel card

Industry recommendations

A card program can be beneficial for any company that has a fleet of drivers and vehicles. However, certain industries, especially trucking and construction, can have unique needs that differ from other businesses, and the card program that's implemented should accommodate those needs. Below are some recommendations for the best fleet fuel card for different fleets.

image column 1 widget_1599591986522

Fuel cards for trucking

Trucking companies normally need fuel cards with nationwide coverage and access to major truck stops. Because of this, we recommend an OTR card for long-haul trucking companies that operate across the U.S. In addition to discounts, you'll want to compare other features like driver services and IFTA and ELD reporting that might be included.

Recommendation

For local and regional trucking companies, however, there are more card options available when doing your fuel card comparison. For example, you might consider the CFN card, which provides access to a discount network. Depending on where you operate, there could be more CFN sites than truck stops available, and the potential savings might outweigh an OTR card. Other features to consider include online access to manage cards and mobile apps to help drivers locate sites and identify site amenities.

image column 1 widget_1599592562779

Fuel cards for construction

Construction firms need fuel cards that provide flexibility and access to various fuel products, especially if they're fueling off-road equipment. The best fuel card for construction companies depends on where you operate and the types of vehicles and equipment in your fleet. 

 

Recommendation

If you're located on the West Coast, for example, a CFN card is recommended. Not only does it provide discounts, but many CFN cardlock locations also carry off-road diesel (dyed diesel) for equipment. If unavailable, ask your vendor about off-road fuel reports that can make it easier to submit fuel tax refunds for those gallons that were not exempted at the time of purchase but still qualify.

If your job locations vary by city or region, a universal card like Voyager or WEX is recommended because of their wide acceptance. While you might not have access to dyed diesel, you will have access to almost all retail gas stations, which is convenient. You'll also be able to set spending limits for cardholders and track company fueling online.

image column 1 widget_1599592669134

Fuel cards for business fleets

For business fleets with needs that can differ greatly by industry, it's difficult to pinpoint one recommended card option. Ultimately, it depends on which features you value most for your operations.

 

Recommendation

For businesses that prefer a broad network of fuel stations, including major and independent brands, a universal card like Voyager or WEX could be useful. For businesses that prioritize discounts and controls, the CFN card could be a fit, especially with retail acceptance that can be added on for flexibility. The good news is that most card options will provide easy-to-use reporting tools and enable you to set spending limits to control costs.

Companies in manufacturing, landscaping, distribution, moving, home repair and agriculture can all benefit from using a fuel card program. If you need help conducting a fleet fuel card comparison, let us know. Our team can review your fleet profile, routes and priorities to help you identify which card would be the best fit. Contact us today.

Common FAQs about fuel card options

Resources for fleet managers and small businesses

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration

A complete database of the laws and regulations for U.S. Commercial Driving Companies

The IRS Trucking Tax Center

Information for Owner-Operators and Small Businesses

Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association 

An advocacy group dedicated to representing truck drivers and owner-operators

The American Trucking Association 

Promotes highway safety, security, environmental sustainability and profitability

FleetOwner 

The information source for commercial truck fleet operations, equipment and technology

Automotive Fleet Comparison 

A comprehensive guide to compare commercial card details with estimated operational costs

Off Road Diesel Locations 

Find locations that provide off road/red dyed diesel.

Gasbuddy.com 

Find the lowest fuel prices in your area and monitor fuel pricing trends.

P-Fleet’s Blog 

Keep up to date with the latest industry news and best practices.

Compare Fuel Cards To Find The One That Fits Your Fleet 

Determine the best card for your company based on the size of your fleet, locations, discounts and fees.

How To Secure Your Fuel Purchasing 

Once you have your cards up and running, you can adjust your restrictions and alerts to prevent fraud or misuse.

How To Reduce Unauthorized Charges With Driver Monitoring 

Quickly spot irregular fueling with driver monitoring and alerts.

How To Choose Between Driver and Vehicle Cards 

Learn the difference between driver and vehicle cards.