Casey's Fuel Card Review: Is it the Right Gas Card for Your Business?

If you’ve ever stopped at Casey's for a slice of pizza, you already know why the brand has such a loyal following. For fleets that regularly fuel at Casey's or Cefco, the Casey’s fuel card is designed to help you capture brand based rebates while adding more control and visibility over your fleet's fuel spend.

It runs on the Fuelman network, so you get access to Casey's locations plus thousands of additional stations nationwide when drivers need flexibility. In this Casey's fuel card review, we’ll break down accepting locations, rebates, fees, controls, reporting, and pros and cons so you can decide if the Casey’s fuel card is the right fit for your business.

Casey's Fuel Card: Overview

What Is the Casey's Fuel Card?

The Casey’s fuel card is a branded business gas card designed for companies that regularly fuel at Casey’s and Cefco locations and want per gallon rebates with basic spending controls and reporting.

It’s issued through Corpay and runs on the Fuelman network, which means it’s accepted at more than 2,900 Casey’s locations, 190+ Cefco stations, and about 60,000 fuel stations nationwide through the broader Fuelman network.

The Casey's fuel card includes Corpay's standard fleet controls like PIN protection, transaction limits, dollar limits, and day and time restrictions. Fleet managers can access real time transaction reports, fuel summary reports, and exception reports to monitor driver activity and flag unusual purchases.

Where Is the Casey's Fuel Card Accepted?
The Casey’s fuel card is accepted at 2,900+ Casey's locations and 190+ Cefco stations, plus the broader Fuelman network, giving you access to about 60,000 fuel stations nationwide. Use the links below to find locations near you.

• Find Casey's stations
• Find Cefco stations
• Find Fuelman locations
  
  

Casey's Fuel Card Discounts

The Casey’s fuel card offers rebates of up to 8¢ per gallon based on your monthly gallons purchased at participating Casey's and Cefco locations. The specific rebate tiers are not published on their website.

Casey's Fuel Card Fees

Casey's fuel card fees are straightforward. There’s a $1.25 per card monthly fee and a late payment fee if you don’t pay your invoice on time.

Casey's Fuel Card Controls and Reporting

Controls

• PIN: Custom number assigned to each card or driver. A valid PIN must be entered to enable fueling.
• Transactions per day: Number of fuel transactions permitted on each card per day.
• Dollars per transaction: Dollar amount a driver can purchase per transaction.
• Dollars per day or week: The number of dollars a driver can purchase in a day or week.
• Day of week: Days when a card can be used.
• Time of day: Hours when a card can be used.
• Fraud protection: Real-time fraud monitoring and alerts.

Reporting

• Purchase alerts: Alerts sent immediately after each transaction.
• Fraud alerts: Email alerts generated if suspicious activity occurs on your account.
• Real-time transaction report: Monitor all fuel purchases.
• Summary reports: See summaries and transaction details. Filter by time period, driver, vehicle, etc.
• Exception reports: Flagged transactions when a card is used outside your designated parameters.
  
  

Pros and Cons of the Casey's Fuel Card

Pros

• Discounts at Casey's and Cefco stations
• Easy to use fuel card management portal

Cons

• Fewer accepting locations than other universal fuel cards
  
  

Casey's Fuel Card Alternatives

If you want to see how the Casey's fuel card compares to other options, check out our list of the best fuel only credit cards.

One strong alternative is the Voyager fuel card, which offers:

• Accepted at 97% of fuel stations
• 8¢ per gallon discount at Casey's and Cefco locations, no volume rebate tiers
• No monthly card fees, account setup fees, late fees, or extended network fees
• Trustpilot rating: 4.8/5
• Free fraud loss coverage